My Home Media Dream
As I get closer to moving into my new place, I've begun to plan and scheme on how best to integrate my media throughout my house. Currently, this all hinges on the speculated abilities of the Xbox 360.
Here's the scenario. I have a fancy Windows Media Center Edition PC that does a fantastic job of recording any TV I want, storing all my photos and music, and serving as a repository for my archived versions of DVD's (there's nothing like having instant access to the entire library of Babylon 5 episodes). Plus, it's got a nice interface and is dead simple to use. (That was my reason for switching from MythTV)
The problem is, I want to get this PC as far away as possible. It's loud, ugly, and annoying to have a keyboard around (even one designed just for it). Bill, being the smart guy that he is, has anticipated this desire, and introduced the concept of a Media Center Extender.
However, that Bill is something of a con man, since these extenders don't behave "exactly" like the MCE PC, just close. The difference being, they'll play WMV, DVR-MS, and MPEG-2, but not my archive of Divx files. The official party line states that is because the devices are all hardware, and the codec support isn't built into the video processing chips on the extenders.
I'm calling BS on that. I don't believe for a second that if Linksys or HP wanted to include these codecs the video processing chips couldn't be programmed with a firmware update to do it. Bill just wants the world to use his WMV format, and consequently, that's all the extenders allow.
So I then began to search for an alternative to a Media Center Extender. There are several devices out there that act as 'Network DVD Players', essentially a DVD player with an ethernet jack and the ability to play back all your favorite audio and video formats. The current front-runner in this category is the IO-Data AVeL Linkplayer2. All of these devices, however, require you to run a 'server' from your PC to stream the media. This is annoying, because in most cases, you're restricted to some weird Windows-only app for media sharing, rather than something simple and intuitive, like an SMB share.
Then I stumbled across the fact that these are almost all simple implementations of the emerging UPnP A/V standard for sharing media content across a LAN. That realization lead me to TwonkyVision, who sell an independent version of this standard that runs on Windows, Mac, Linux, and get this, the Linksys NSLU2! Score! Now we're talking. Nothing says home media like a little appliance for serving up files, all sans loud, obnoxious PC. This seems like a perfect fit.
So I've got this dream of a NSLU2 sitting in my house, serving up all my content via UPnP A/V goodness to any of the numerous devices that accept it, but still no ability nor simple interface to access captured MCE TV shows. Bummer. So I add a Media Center Extender to the mix for remote viewing of recorded TV. But, at this point I'm looking at a network DVD player for Divx and a Media Center Extender for TV. Two devices is certainly one too many.
But wait. The Xbox 360 has full support to act as a Media Center Extender right out of the box. In addition to that, it will also support the new "Windows Media Connect" standard. This is Bill's version of MCE for non-MCE versions of Windows. It'll allow all the PC's in your house to share music, photos, and video with a compatible 'Digital Media Receiver', including of course, the Xbox 360. Sound familiar? It should, because it's just Bill's implementation of UPnP A/V for Windows.
So, UPnP A/V supports a variety of formats, including Divx. Will the Xbox team surprise us all and include that? Will it work with any UPnP A/V server? Will this one box be the $299 answer to my multi-box home media viewing woes? If this does have all the support I need, I'll be screaming from the rooftops the beauty of the Bill's vision of the digital home.
If not, I'll continue to be annoyed by MSFT, and end up with some hodge-podge solution of MythTV, video transcoding, and 150' S-Video cables strewn throughout my house.
For now I'm going to sit and wait for the various MCE bigwigs to leak out the news that I'm totally insane for even dreaming of this, or that my vision of home media consolidation is coming to fruition sometime in November.


